Melissa Kite seems to think that European kids all grow up to become raging alcoholics thanks to being given alcohol by their parents round the dinner table:
Speaking to a group of young people (always a dangerous set-up) [David Cameron] said: “Some of the friends I had, the ones who had the biggest problems, were the ones who actually were never allowed to drink anything at home – whereas the ones who drink responsibly were the ones who were given a glass of wine or a small glass of beer or a shandy or something. That’s the right way to do it in the home.”
If the answer to alcoholism really is to teach children how to drink, then why don’t the Tories propose giving away free Dubonnet and soda in schools during break time, or perhaps little bottles of vodka and red bull at lunch.
That would also give them the idea, as Mr Cameron says, ‘that drinking is something you can do socially, and something you can do with a meal, and something that is part of life’.
Her argument is utterly vacuous and without merit, and I’m only posting about it because I’ve recently been thinking along very similar lines to what Cameron has said this morning. There was quite a good letter from ‘A. Tory’ on this issue just the other day, as well.
By offering young teenagers alcohol at home in a safe environment, a large amount of the mystique of alcohol just disappears. Being restrictive with the stuff is just encouraging them to think of it as forbidden fruit. As I may have alluded to already, this already is extremely common in mainland Europe, and it is not France or Spain that have a problem with excessive binge drinking, nor an association of violence with alcohol consumption. A responsible parent ought to be able to allow their 12-year-old child a small glass of wine or Bacardi Breezer or something at the dinner table or at a family barbeque.
(Hat-Tip Guido)

I agree on all counts. My response to Melissa Kite is a string of four-letter words. She is more interested in curtain-twitching than in actually solving society’s problems…
I agree with your analysis and add that age restrictions in pubs should be relaxed so long as a responsible adult is present and the landlord presides over things responsibly. This will keep youngsters off the supermarket cider and what have you. Creating a veil of mystery over these things only makes matters worse.
The control freaks, the Tory Taliban, the Daily Mail tendency and the puritanical virgins on the left should be vanquished.
asquith
July 31, 2008 at 3:05 pm